Est. Bethpage, NY

Tradition in
Every Bite

Hand-rolled daily using time-honored recipes. Experience the authentic taste of New York's finest bagels, right here in the heart of Bethpage.

Get Directions View Menu

Fresh Daily

Baked every morning

We start at 4 AM so you can taste the difference of truly fresh dough.

Artisan Quality

Premium ingredients

No preservatives. Just flour, water, yeast, salt, and passion.

Local Favorite

Bethpage staple

Proudly serving our community with warmth and hospitality for years.

Baking with Heart & History

At Bethpage Bagels, we believe that a great bagel isn't just breakfast—it's a ritual. Located on North Wantagh Avenue, we've been a cornerstone of the Bethpage community, bringing the authentic flavors of New York baking to your neighborhood.

Our process is simple but exacting: we hand-roll every bagel, boil it to perfection, and bake it until it shines. The result is a bagel with a crisp, golden crust and a soft, chewy interior that simply cannot be replicated by machines.

Hand-rolled daily
Premium imported flour
Locally sourced toppings

Our Menu

Signature Selections

From classic plain to our famous everything, explore the varieties that keep our customers coming back.

The Classic Plain

The true test of a baker. Perfectly chewy interior with a dusting of flour and a golden crust.

Rich Egg Bagel

Enriched with real eggs for a yellow hue and a tender, cake-like crumb that pairs perfectly with butter.

Everything Bagel

Our crowd favorite. Generously topped with sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and salt.

Soft Pretzel Bagel

A unique twist on the classic. Coarse salt and a deep brown boil give this bagel a distinct savory flavor.

Cinnamon Raisin

Sweet, spiced, and studded with plump raisins. The perfect start to a lazy Sunday morning.

Sesame Seed

Nutty and delicate. A versatile bagel that stands up to both savory lox spreads and simple cream cheese.

Plus many more varieties available daily. Ask about our gluten-free options!

Words from Our Neighbors

"The best bagels in Nassau County, hands down. They are always fresh, warm, and have that perfect chew. A true Bethpage gem."

— Local Resident

"I stop by every morning on my way to work. The staff is incredibly friendly and the coffee is strong. It's the perfect start to the day."

— Regular Customer

"Nothing beats a fresh Everything bagel with scallion cream cheese. Simple, classic, and done right. Highly recommend!"

— Food Enthusiast

Find Us

Visit Bethpage Bagels

We are conveniently located on North Wantagh Avenue. Come in for a fresh bagel, a quick coffee, or order ahead for your morning commute.

Address

442 N Wantagh Ave
Bethpage, NY 11714

Phone

Call us for orders or questions

(516) 931-8428

Hours

Mon - Fri: 6:00 AM - 3:00 PM

Sat - Sun: 7:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Tradition in Every Bite